Click Here for AirGunHome.com Main Page
Argentina Australia Belgium Canada Chile Denmark France Germany Greece India
Italy Mexico New Zealand Netherlands Norway Russian Federation South Africa Spain Turkey United Kingdom United States
AirGunHome.com: THE Worldwide Airgun Forum


AirGunSeals.com Main Page Link
Air Gun Home Forum Index Register FAQ Memberlist Search

Air Gun Home Forum Index » Rifles » For the Love of Carbines
Post new topic  Reply to topic View previous topic :: View next topic 
For the Love of Carbines 
PostPosted: Wed Nov 30, 2011 2:01 pm Reply with quote
rsterne
Moderator
Moderator
Joined: 15 Jan 2008
Posts: 2998
Location: Coalmont, BC
As a result of some questions via PMs from various members.... and in trying to answer their questions as accurately as possible.... I have "discovered" some things that may be of interest to anyone comtemplating building a Carbine.... Well to be fair, I knew them already, intuitively, but now I can put some numbers on them.... I was able to "do the numbers" primarily because of a spreadsheet from Lloyd which should perhaps be called "The PCP from Click to Bang" (with apologies to the Cardew brothers' books "The Airgun from Trigger to Muzzle/Target").... It is becoming invaluable to me, many thanks, Lloyd....

One of the most frequently asked questions is "how long should I make the barrel".... The answer, from a performance point of view, is inevitably "as long as possible".... With the help of Lloyd's spreadsheet, I can take a PCP (or CO2, maybe a pumper) rifle of known performance, substitute a shorter (or longer) barrel length, and determine quite accurately what would happen if you change the barrel length.... The answer depends on many factors, but the starting point is the air pressure and volume, velocity, air usage, and barrel length.... Knowing those, I play with the other variables in the program until I get the numbers agreeing with the baseline rifle.... Then by simply changing the barrel length (and nothing else) the spreadsheet predicts a new velocity and energy for the new length....

I'll give you an example, starting with my .25 cal Disco.... It has a 135 cc air reservoir, filled to 2100 psi, and returns 11 shots of 45 FPE (25.4 gr. @ 893 fps avg.) from it's 24" barrel.... Here is what the spreadsheet tells me for different barrel lengths.... It won't be perfect, but this should be a very close approximation....

24" - 45.0 FPE
22" - 43.3 FPE (3.7% loss)
20" - 41.5 FPE (7.8% loss)
19" - 40.5 FPE (10% loss)
18" - 39.4 FPE (12.4% loss)
16" - 37.1 FPE (17.5% loss)
15" - 35.8 FPE (20.4% loss)
14" - 34.5 FPE (23.4% loss)
12" - 31.4 FPE (30.2% loss)

I highlighted some of the lengths to demonstrate the trend.... The first 5" you cut off the barrel loses 10%.... The next 4" loses another 10%.... and the next 3" loses yet another 10%.... At half the barrel length, you are down over 30% in FPE.... Incidently, adding 6" to the barrel length (ie a 30" barrel) adds about 10% to the energy.... Now if you start with a gun that has a lot less power, the losses are less, not only in absolute numbers, but in percentages as well.... Let's start with a gun with less than half the power in .22 cal.... 20 FPE (18.1 gr. @ 706 fps) from a 24" barrel.... Here are the results....

24" - 20 FPE
17" - 17.9 FPE (10.3% loss)
12" - 15.7 FPE (21.3% loss)

This time it takes about 7" off the barrel to lose 10% in energy.... and half the barrel length drops the energy just over 21%.... compared to a 30% loss in the more powerful gun.... There are a lot of variables, particularly in a PCP, that can sway these results.... Higher pressures and very short valve timing will generally produce less losses with short barrels.... Lower pressures and long valve timing will not work well in short barrels, as eventually it will become a "dump shot" where the valve is still open when the pellet has left the barrel, simply wasting air.... This shows why Crosman took the approach they did with the PRod.... high pressures and limited valve timing because of the short barrel.... Otherwise you waste a lot of air, especially if you are trying for big FPE....

One other thing I discovered when running these numbers through Lloyd's spreadsheet.... The number of shots apparently stays the same, even though the FPE is less.... That means that the efficiency is dropping by the same amount as the FPE numbers.... I guess I also knew this intuitively, but seeing the numbers really brought it home.... Using the first example, cutting the barrel in half not only dropped the power by 30%.... it reduced the efficiency by the same percentage.... You are using the same amount of air to produce the same number of shots, but at 30% less FPE.... Shocked

I hope this information is useful to any of you contemplating building a Carbine.... The lesson is, cut that barrel with care.... or the gun will likely not live up to your expectations.... Here is a specific example, starting with my .25 Disco.... Let's use a 19" barrel to limit the loss to 10%.... Let's shorten the air reservoir by 5" as well.... That reduces it from 135 cc to 100 cc instead of 135.... The resulting Carbine should produce about 8 shots at 40.5 FPE.... Cut two more inches off the barrel (17") and air reservoir (85 cc).... and the spreadsheet predicts 7 shots at 38.3 FPE....

Bob

_________________
Dominion Marksman Silver Shield - 5890 x 6000 in 1976, and downhill ever since!
Airsonal: Too many to count!
View user's profile Send private message
For the Love of Carbines 
  Air Gun Home Forum Index » Rifles
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
All times are GMT - 5 Hours  
Page 1 of 1  

  
  
 Post new topic  Reply to topic  

Note: If you are seeing "Please enter your username and password to log in." Your browser cookies have been reset
or you need to register to access the topic in question. Use the 'Register' button near the top left of this page.


Click Here for AirGunHome.com Main Page


Powered by phpBB © 2001-2004 phpBB Group
Partial Styling Supplied by Vjacheslav Trushkin Themes Database.